Sa1nt's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[EgoCity Chap V disk1]

Very Nice

I dont think alot of the people who've reviewed this realise the amount of effort you actually put in, i dont think its right to ask you to improve the graphics as i believe they were rather well done, simplicity is the key to most things, and it works well in this animation with regards to the faces, the backgrounds and atmosphere of the scenes were incredible, and the detail in parts of the animation of things like hands or the sea were second to none, should be proud, overall it was a very good animation and i ranked it 10, and gave it a 5.

[Zombie Noodles 2]

Meh

Twas alright mate, although, i think you should just stop and think about the things it lacks:

length - i know you said its longer, but not long enough
Sound - IE voices, develops depth of character
Graphics - On the whole ok, but the blood needed realism
Plot - this perticular sort of plot, needs fast paced animation to pull it off i belive, as i've seen ones similiar to it.

Other than that, wasnt the worst thing i've seen all day.

ZombieNoodles responds:

Alrighty ill work on some thing.
but right now the plan is to make a "season"(10eps) of black and white no voices
then i might go color with voices or stay black and white with voices.

[Unrelated Occurences]

Woah

Sometimes when i watch some of the flash animations that enter newgrounds it stuns me to fathom how they are made, and this is one of those animations where i have no idea how you did it, without dedicating a large amount of your time to it, enlighten me?

billyjr82 responds:

Wow thanks for that, just IM one of us and we'll let ya know...keep in mind that Ben did the first half and I did the second..peace ~Billy

[Tony: Part One]

Twas Good

I liked that, i thought it was pretty decent, also quite into all that music, twasn't bad.

[Suicide is Good!]

Interesting

Morbid, i like it.
shame some of the people who've reviewed this dislike it and feel the need to insult you.

honestly it was that bad, perhaps if you'd left out the suidcide angle, it would be more widely accepted, i understand thats the point of the flash but im sure there could have been other reasons other than suicide, but either way voted 5.

[-LINED-]

Kewl

That was really good actually, only a couple of things i thought could have made it better, and dont think i'm being pedantic or anything, just a few opinions

could have done with the speed of the animation matching the music.
and you probably should have chosen a more fast paced song for the animation.

Other than that, it was really cool.

[Grab It By The Horns Ad]

Hate Me

Cant really call that much of an animtion, most of it was images you poorly cropped and made cross the screen randomly perhaps if you'd animated some of it via the skills of drawing it might have been good, but since you didn't i found it rather dull and pointless. and personally, i dont think that deserves a pass in whatever lesson you had to make it for. Sorry

Mikaelus responds:

Nah, I can't hate you. That's some valid criticism (if a bit harsh). I admit there was no real animation skill on display here, but I hoped people would like the comedy of it. Sorry you didn't enjoy it, when I make a well animated movie I'll let you know.